Described
on the cover as 'An Intimate History of the Black Death' (a name which, interestingly, was never used by
contemporaries and arose from a mistranslation), this is a
charming introduction to a fascinating and gory topic that can actually justify
the numerous hymns of praise plastered across the back.
The Great Mortality focuses on the
progress of the Black Death across Europe from its beginning in Russia,
describing both the probable causes of the contagion and its effects on the
population. Interwoven are the histories
of the places plague visited,
the events preceding the plague - such as the Great Famine - and the history of Yersinia Pestis
itself, including its discovery and its appearances before and after the Black
Death.
The
book is not without imperfections. There were worrying discrepancies between
the book's account of how the plague bacillus was identified and other accounts
I have read - though, to be fair, there is no reason to assume they were more
reliable. Editorial mistakes are more common than they should be (epitaph is,
in one entertaining incident, confused with epithet) and the final chapter -
which deals with 'plague deniers' (those who think the Black Death was not
caused by Yersinia Pestis) - feels like it needs more work,
and has employed some circular arguments.
On
the other hand, The Great Mortality has the great merit of being
immensely readable. The writing style is beautifully clear, while the
interspersion of anecdotes - for example, the Sienan merchant who lost his wife
and five sons to plague - really impresses upon the reader the tragedy the
epidemic brought, and the addition of contemporary events to the book, like the
trial of Johanna of Naples for the murder of her husband, allows the reader to
imagine the outbreak in context. Overall, the book is an immensely entertaining
introduction to the Black Death, and worth recommending.
WS
No comments:
Post a Comment